Yoder's Pie Craft Coffee Co.

Kira S Edited a month ago

Such a cute little spot! We tried the iced matcha latte with fresh strawberry purée and it was so good. They use ceremonial-grade matcha, and you can definitely taste the quality. The fresh strawberry purée added such a nice fruity touch without making it too sweet. The iced vanilla latte was also really well made smooth, refreshing and not overly sweet. There are so many baked goods to choose from, and I loved seeing the simple, recognizable ingredients used in their baking. We grabbed the banana bread to take with us and it was delicious! The shop itself is really cute with lots of goodies to browse, from cookies and other baked treats to packaged items and little souvenirs. They even had things like locally made tallow lip balm. Definitely worth stopping by if you’re in the area. Great drinks, lots of treats to choose from, and a really cute atmosphere!

nicole tran 3 months ago

Recently moved to Sarasota from a more urban area with unlimited coffee shops so, of course, I was in search of a good coffee in this town— The specialty drinks really did it for me! IMO best lattes around here

Anthony Palermo 4 months ago

Absolutely, outstanding amazing place. This portion of the Yoder Villages, the pie and coffee shop. It looks like they have tons of fresh made soups as well as little pies and pastries and cookies. A great coffee bar. Got the iced chai without milk and cookie butter syrup and it is absolutely phenomenal outstanding! It’s like drinking Fall in a cup. Super friendly and service oriented staff. And their dinner rolls… Wow! So light and fluffy super fresh yeast rolls. In love. Will return here for sure. Restaurant gift shop looks amazing as well.

Cheridan Smith 4 months ago

I love the coffee drinks here. Probably my favorite in Sarasota and they offer huge sizes which I love. I always come back to the cookie butter latte but the brown sugar macchiato is amazing too. I had the turkey club today too on rye. It was fabulous, a bit pricey because it didn’t come with chips or even a pickle, but still enjoyed it. I’ll be back for more coffee very soon! I need a rewards number, lol.

Shannon Heitner 7 months ago

We were visiting from MN and looking for a good local coffee shop to try and so we stopped at Yoder's. Best decision ever. The coffee is fantastic and they have so many customizing options. Also the pricing is SO reasonable for the size coffee you get. I was shocked at how cheap it was for how good quality it is. I would highly recommend stopping by.